Darragh Coffey represented the family of 12-year-old girl, who died after drinking a milkshake that had been contaminated with hazelnut residue, at the inquest into her death in South Inner London Coroner’s Court. Mia St Hilaire, who was allergic to tree nuts, including hazelnuts, became ill after drinking a small amount of a milkshake that had been ordered for her at the Pop Inn Café on Southwark Park Road in London in August 2023. Mia’s condition quickly deteriorated and she suffered anaphylaxis. Mia was brought to hospital by ambulance but despite extensive emergency medical treatment Mia sadly passed away a short time later.
Following three days of evidence HM Assistant Coroner Briony Ballard found that the blender in which Mia’s milkshake, a Twix milkshake, had been made had previously been used to make a Kinder Bueno Milkshake and had not been washed between uses. Kinder Bueno contains approximately 10% hazelnuts and the residue in the blender was found to have cross contaminated Mia’s milkshake and caused her anaphylactic reaction.
Throughout the course of the evidence the Coroner heard that when the Café was inspected in 2020 concerns were raised by Southwark Council in relation to aspects of the businesses’ allergen management procedures and information. However, the café was still awarded the top food hygiene rating of five out of five because at that time allergen management was considered to fall under the food standards inspection system, which did not have an equivalent public facing rating.
The Coroner agreed with submissions made on behalf of the family that such non-compliances in 2020 could have been taken as warning signs that there were further deficiencies in the understanding of allergen management at the café.
HMAC Briony Ballard returned a narrative conclusion and indicated that she would be issuing a report to prevent future deaths addressed to the Food Standards Agency, Southwark Council and the Pop Inn Café.
In January 2025, the proprietor of the Pop Inn Café was sentenced to fines totalling £18,000 and a 100-hour community order, having pleaded guilty to six food safety offences arising out of this incident.
Darragh was instructed on behalf of Mia’s family by Michelle Victor, head of the Food Safety Team at Leigh Day, and Angela Bruno, Senior Associate at Leigh Day.
Press Coverage: