Matthew Howarth, instructed by the Government Legal Department, represented the Secretary of State for the Home Department in a judicial review raising important questions about procedural fairness, the construction of the Home Office sponsor guidance and the application of section 31(2A) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 to decisions revoking sponsor licences.

Background

Moon Fish Ltd held a sponsor licence under the Skilled Worker route and sponsored three migrant workers. Following an HMRC data check, UK Visas and Immigration wrote to the company on 20 October 2025 stating that it was investigating concerns that sponsored workers might not be receiving the salary stated on their certificates of sponsorship, citing Annex C1(aa) of the sponsor guidance and requesting payroll and employment records. The company supplied the documents without commentary.

Those records showed that one worker had been paid £3,560.51 less than his headline annual salary in May and June 2025. The shortfall arose because he had taken a period of unpaid compassionate leave of around two months. It was common ground that the leave and the reduced pay were lawful in employment law and were not, in themselves, prohibited by the sponsorship scheme. The company accepted, however, that it had failed to report the absence as the guidance required.

Without seeking an explanation for the discrepancy, the Secretary of State revoked the licence with immediate effect on 18 November 2025, treating the unreported shortfall as satisfying the mandatory ground of revocation in Annex C1(aa). The company’s explanation was first provided in pre-action correspondence, following which the decision was maintained.

The judgment

Thomas Raphael KC, sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court, quashed the decision and remitted it to the Secretary of State for reconsideration. Three principles emerge from the judgment.

  • Construction of Annex C1(aa). The Court held that a reduced payment arising from a period of unpaid leave that is otherwise permissible under the scheme does not, without more, constitute a “change in salary” within Annex C1(aa). The failure to report such leave is a breach of the sponsor’s reporting duties under section S4 and paragraph C1.13, and so capable of engaging the discretionary ground in Annex C2(a), but the mandatory ground in Annex C1 requires clearer language if it is to capture that situation [71]. The decision had reasoned from the bare fact of a lower payment and the absence of a report to a finding of an Annex C1(aa) breach, and in doing so had misdirected itself [87-91 & 142-147].
  • Procedural fairness. The Court held that the sponsorship scheme does not displace the common law requirement that a sponsor be told the gist of the specific case against it and be given a reasonable opportunity to respond before revocation, even where the Secretary of State considers that a mandatory ground is made out and even where no dishonesty is alleged [128-129]. The general request for documents of 20 October did not satisfy that requirement because it did not identify the particular worker or payment of concern. Once the records had been analysed, fairness required a further step identifying the specific discrepancy and inviting an explanation before revocation [130-141].
  • Section 31(2A). The Court declined to refuse relief on the basis that the outcome would highly likely have been the same. The decision had been founded on the mandatory ground; Annex C2(a) had not been clearly relied upon as an independent basis for revocation; the admitted breach was a single reporting failure concerning one worker’s otherwise legitimate leave; and no other compliance concerns had been identified. In those circumstances there was a realistic prospect that a lesser sanction would have been imposed, and the Secretary of State had adduced no evidence of a practice of revoking for reporting breaches of that kind [153-159].

Comment

The judgment was handed down on the same day as the Court of Appeal’s decision in R (J’s Supermarket Ltd) v SSHD; R (Prestige Social Care Services Ltd) v SSHD [2026] EWCA Civ 1147, in which Matthew successfully appeared for the Secretary of State. That judgment confirms the continuing relevance of the residual discretion not to revoke even where a mandatory ground is established, and emphasises that the legal basis on which the Secretary of State proceeds matters: Annex C1 and Annex C2 involve different decision-making frameworks and different consequences for the sponsor. The Court reiterated, following Prestwick Care, that the Secretary of State is not obliged to assess the impact of revocation on the sponsor or its workers, although she may take those matters into account [100].